Retro Spooktacles continues Wrong Place, Wrong Time with Teddy’s pick, Creep, Patrick Brice’s 2014 found-footage horror film that asks how long you can keep giving a stranger the benefit of the doubt. A $1,000 Craigslist gig brings a videographer to an isolated cabin, where every awkward joke and crossed boundary makes staying harder to justify.

Patrick Brice stars as Aaron, hired to film Josef (Mark Duplass), who claims he’s making a video for his unborn child. What begins as an uncomfortable but seemingly harmless assignment grows increasingly unsettling as Josef shifts between vulnerable, goofy, and threatening, introducing a disturbing wolf mask called Peachfuzz along the way.

Mitcz and Teddy debate whether Josef is obviously dangerous from the start or just a deeply awkward guy, the warning signs Aaron overlooks, and how Duplass turns social discomfort into genuine dread. They also compare their real-life Craigslist experiences, explore why the film’s intimate found-footage approach works, and measure Creep’s influence on “you should have left an hour ago” horror with the Zeitgeistometer.

Get your spectacles on and join us!